Which encounter demonstrates Holden misreading a caring adult's concern?

• A. The two nuns' kindness
• B. Phoebe's reproach
• C. Jane Gallagher's memory
• D. Mr. Antolini's visit

Answer: (D)

Holden often reads any adult who tries to help him through a distorted lens, so this encounter with Mr. Antolini best shows a caring adult being misinterpreted. Antolini is genuinely trying to guide Holden—he talks about the difficulty of growing up, warns him about the phoniness of the world, and offers a safe, supportive place to stay. The moment that sticks is when Antolini strokes Holden’s head while he’s asleep and then speaks in a caring, almost paternal voice. Holden interprets that gesture as something inappropriate or alarming, not as a mentor’s concern, and he reacts with distrust and a abrupt departure. This misreading highlights Holden’s habit of reading adult kindness as something risky or manipulative, instead of genuine concern.