Which character's memory reveals Holden's longing for sincerity?

• A. Jane Gallagher
• B. Phoebe
• C. Mr. Antolini
• D. The ducks

Answer: (A)

Holden’s longing for sincerity is most powerfully shown through his memory of Jane Gallagher. Jane stands out as a real, uncomplicated presence from Holden’s past—someone who treated him with genuine kindness and was unpretentious, unlike the phoniness he sees in much of the adult world. That memory—how Jane listened, cared, and kept things straightforward—acts as a touchstone for what Holden wants from people: authenticity and a true connection. Because Jane represents honest, unperformative interactions, recalling her brings into focus Holden’s deep craving for sincerity in himself and others. The other figures touch on different aspects of his experience—Phoebe points to innocence and protective instinct, Mr. Antolini to guidance (and unease), the ducks to change and uncertainty—but none pin down that wish for sincerity as clearly as Jane Gallagher.