What does Holden's reaction to Phoebe's broken record reveal about his relationship with her?

• A. He ignores Phoebe and her belongings.
• B. He blames Phoebe for breaking the record.
• C. He is deeply affected, crying and protective of Phoebe.
• D. He thinks Phoebe is being childish.

Answer: (C)

Holden’s reaction to Phoebe’s broken record shows a deeply caring, protective side that his tough, sarcastic exterior often hides. When the record breaks, he isn’t annoyed or blaming Phoebe; he’s visibly affected, even moved to tears, and he immediately acts to comfort her and to set things right. This moment highlights how important Phoebe is to him and how he wants to shield her from the harshness of the world. Their bond is warm and genuine, with Holden treating his sister as someone he must protect and support, not a nuisance or a burden.