What does Holden's gesture toward the two nuns reflect about his moral complexity?

• A. He resents the nuns and perceives them as trivial.
• B. He is indifferent and avoids interaction.
• C. He criticizes their values openly.
• D. He shows generosity and tenderness despite his cynicism, indicating moral depth.

Answer: (D)

The idea being tested is Holden’s moral complexity—the way cynicism about the world can coexist with genuine care for other people. When he talks with the two nuns on the train, he treats them with warmth and civility, listens to them, and then offers money to help them. That act isn’t about vanity or self-satisfaction; it shows a sincere concern for others and a readiness to do something kind, even though he often views adults and society with cynical eyes. This moment reveals that his ethics aren’t black-and-white: he can be skeptical and harsh, yet also generous and tender. That combination—cynicism paired with outward generosity—points to real moral depth.