What does Holden give to Phoebe?

• A. A new jacket.
• B. The broken record pieces.
• C. His red hunting hat.
• D. His father's wallet.

Answer: (C)

Holden’s red hunting hat is given to Phoebe, and it carries a lot of meaning. The hat is a personal symbol for Holden—an awkward, protective piece that helps him feel unique and safe in a world he often finds overwhelming. When he gives it to Phoebe, he’s handing her a piece of himself and a way to feel protected by her, signaling his wish to preserve her innocence and their close bond. It’s less about a practical gift and more about passing on something intimate that represents care, connection, and the desire to shield someone from the harsher parts of growing up. The other items don’t fit this moment because they don’t symbolize Holden’s protective impulse or his relationship with Phoebe in the same way.