How does Holden respond to his encounter with the nuns?

• A. He ignores them and keeps walking
• B. He is generous and compassionate, wanting to do what is right despite cynicism
• C. He lectures them about life
• D. He tries to sell them something

Answer: (B)

This question centers on Holden’s capacity for generosity and genuine care in a moment that tests his cynicism. When he meets the nuns, he responds with kindness by offering them money and engaging with them politely, choosing to help despite his own worries and the world’s phoniness he often criticizes. This act shows a real impulse to do what feels right, even if it’s small, and it highlights the complexity of Holden’s character—he can be bitter about society yet still be moved to help someone in need. He doesn’t ignore them, lecture them, or try to hawk something; he simply shares what he has and treats them with respect, which is why this moment stands out.